Here's a ranked listing of Fonts.com Web Fonts' top 100 most used Web fonts for September 2011:
Avenir® 55 Roman
Futura® Bold
Avenir® 95 Black, Ext.
Neue Helvetica® 55 Roman
Neue Helvetica® 35 Thin
Avenir® 85 Heavy
Univers® 57 Condensed
Neue Helvetica® 75 Bold
Neue Helvetica® 77 Condensed Bold
Garamond 3 Regular
Garamond 3 Italic
Bauer Bodoni® Black Italic
Sackers™ Gothic Heavy
Sackers™ Gothic Medium
Avenir® 65 Medium
Trade Gothic® Condensed Bold #20, Ext.
Avenir® 35 Light
Neue Helvetica® 45 Light
Neue Helvetica® 87 Condensed Heavy
Trade Gothic® Condensed Bold 20
Trade Gothic® Bold
Helvetica® Condensed Bold
Neue Helvetica® 25 Ultra Light
Futura Medium
Neue Helvetica® 57 Condensed
Administer BookItalic
Avenir® 95 Black
Linotype Univers® 620 Condensed Bold
Linotype Didot® Bold
Linotype Didot® Roman
Linotype Univers® 420 Condensed
Linotype Didot® Italic
Neue Helvetica® 67 Condensed Medium
Linotype Univers® 320 Condensed Light, Ext.
Futura® Book
Univers® 47 Condensed Light Oblique, Ext.
Trade Gothic® Roman
Avenir® 45 Book
Futura® Heavy
Futura® Bold Condensed
Futura® Medium Condensed
PMN Caecilia® 75 Bold
PMN Caecilia® 85 Heavy
Neue Helvetica® 45 Light, Ext.
Trade Gothic® Bold 2
PMN Caecilia® 76 Bold Italic
ITC Avant Garde Gothic® Book
Neue Helvetica® 65 Medium
Monotype Grotesque® Condensed
Neue Helvetica® 37 Condensed Thin
Neue Helvetica® 47 Condensed Light
Neue Frutiger® Light
Trade Gothic® Bold, Ext.
Neue Frutiger® Bold
Neue Frutiger® Book
ITC Legacy® Serif Bold Italic
Neue Helvetica® 55 Roman, Ext.
VAG Rounded™ Bold
Rockwell® Bold
Trade Gothic® Condensed 18
Univers® 67 Condensed Bold Oblique
Avenir® 55 Roman, Ext.
Trade Gothic® Extended Bold
Felbridge™ Regular
Neue Helvetica® 77 Condensed Bold, Ext.
Cochin® Roman
Neuzeit® Office Bold
Neuzeit® Office Regular, Ext.
VAG Rounded™ Black
ITC Avant Garde Gothic® Medium
Neue Helvetica® 63 Extended Medium
Neue Helvetica® 53 Extended, Ext.
Frutiger® 65 Bold
Neue Helvetica® 73 Extended Bold, Ext.
DIN Next™ Bold
Frutiger® 55 Roman
Trade Gothic® Bold #2, Ext.
DIN Next™ Regular
ITC Avant Garde Gothic® Bold
VAG Rounded™ Light
Trade Gothic Next Regular
Helvetica® Bold, Ext.
Helvetica® Bold
Trade Gothic® Condensed #18, Ext.
Neue Helvetica® 65 Medium, Ext.
DIN 1451 Engschrift
DIN Next™ Condensed Bold
Frutiger® 45 Light, Ext.
Neo Sans Regular, Ext.
ITC Avant Garde Gothic® Demi
Palatino® Sans Arabic Regular
Avenir® Next Demi
Trade Gothic Next Condensed Bold
Eurostile® Next Regular
Eurostile® Next Extended Regular
Trade Gothic® Light
Eurostile® Next Extended Bold
Eurostile® Next Extended Semibold
Eurostile® Next Semi Bold, Ext.
Gill Sans® Book